A Carnival ship docked in New Orleans can still sail around the oil spill - but for how long?

Cruise Lines' Dirty Work?

By paul motter

Two obscure maritime laws have come under scrutiny since the BP Oil Rig disaster. First is the Death on the High Seas Act (DOHSA), second is the Jones Act. Both laws were enacted in 1920, during the presidency of Woodrow Wilson.

The Death on the High Seas Act limits the liability of a "carrier" operating in international waters (whether it is a ship, jet or oil rig) in the case of death due to negligence. It says the deceased worker's dependents are entitled to compensation equal to what he would have earned over his lifetime in the same job.

DOHSA critics say this is unfair, that if a person dies "in the line of duty" the family should be entitled to pain and suffering, alienation of affection and punitive damages.

Now, if a soldier or a policeman is killed in the line of duty his family is not entitled to sue the government for anything. Why? Because the people knew the dangers when they took the job and the amount of family compensation is pre-determined by law. Without these limits these jobs could not exist.

However, it is extremely important that we warn you, as cruise ship passengers, that the Death on the High Seas Act also applies to you. Should you be killed while cruising on a cruise ship, by some highly extraordinary set of circumstances, the amount for which your family can sue the cruise line has the same limitations. This is yet another reason to recommend travel insurance to cruisers for anywhere from one to twenty million dollars in the case of accidental death.

The Jones Act is a law that I never expected to see in national headlines. It limits the right to conduct business in U.S. territorial waters to vessels that were built in the U.S., are currently flagged in the U.S. and only employ legal United States residents as crewmembers.

Cruise ships from Carnival, Royal Caribbean and other major cruise lines are not U.S.-flagged and so they are limited by the Jones Act.

Many people are now calling on President Obama to suspend the Jones Act so non-U.S.-flagged ships can work in our territorial waters cleaning up the oil spill. President Bush suspended it within two weeks of the Katrina Hurricane crisis, for example. But Obama has yet to give clearance to some 20 foreign nations who are ready to assist in the cleanup.

Apparently, the Dutch have ships with vacuum technology that could clean up the oil spill about five times faster than any U.S.-flagged technology. To be clear, most are not volunteering their efforts, they expect to be paid.

But here is one context Mother Jones and many other pundits have missed; Repealing the Jones Act now would have an immediate benefit to the oil spill cleanup. But for the DOHSA; ex post facto law (the application of a new law to an instance that occurred before the law was changed) is expressly forbidden by Article One of the Constitution. Therefore, repealing the DOHSA wouldn't help the BP widows in any way.

Discuss this article in our CruiseMates Forums: Cruise Lines Doing BP's Dirty Work?

We want your cruise reviews!

CruiseMates started publishing our readers' cruise reviews long before other web sites even thought of it. We already have thousands of reviews online, but there are never enough! CruiseMates and our sister site cruisereviews.com both want more of YOUR cruise reviews. So, please send them to us:

  • To submit a cruise review to CruiseReviews.com, please go here.

  • To submit a cruise review to CruiseMates, please go here .
hr blue bar
7-night Carnival cruise from $449
Carnival Glory roundtrip from Miami to Nassau, St Thomas, San Juan, Grand Turk.
•  America's Vacation Center (866) 501-7271
CM says: Exotic itinerary, balcony cabins from $719, a great cruise bargain
hr blue bar
NCL 4-Day Freestyle Dash Sales Event June 15-18!
Book a select 2010 NCL Cruise and receive FREE TRAVEL INSURANCE, 50% reduced deposit, and up to $300 in onboard credit per stateroom!
•  Direct Line Cruises 1-800-352-8088
CM says: Must book by June 18 to qualify!
hr blue bar
The New Cruise Ships Are Coming! ALLURE, OASIS, EPIC, SILHOUETTE!
Book one of the NEW Cruise Ships and receive up to $200 onboard credit, FREE TRAVEL INSURANCE, 110% Rate Protection Guarantee, chance to win a FREE upgrade to a VILLA or SUITE, and an onboard savings booklet!
•  Direct Line Cruises 1-800-352-8088
CM says: Must book by June 30 to qualify!
hr blue bar
Royal Caribbean Hot Deals! starting from $398
Royal Caribbean 8-night Caribbean cruises from as low as $50 per person per night!
•  CruiseMagic 1-800-474-5678
CM says: Dozens of Royal Caribbean deals at great prices - click above.
hr blue bar
7-night Princess Caribbean cruise: $549
Roundtrip from Ft Lauderdale to Princess Cays, Ocho Rios, Grand Cayman and Cozumel.
•  America's Vacation Center (866) 501-7271
CM Note: An INCREDIBLE peak-season bargain on a premium ship; balcony just $799
hr blue bar
Oceania Cruises on Sale!
Oceania Cruises: 2011 Alaska Summer Collection roundtrip San Francisco! Amenities and 2for1 fares!
•  CRUISE MARKETPLACE 1-800-826-4333
CM says: Great cruise line on its inaugural Alaska season!
hr blue bar
7-night Western Caribbean cruise from $399
Norwegian Pearl roundtrip from Miami to Belize, Roatan, Costa Maya and Key West.
•  America's Vacation Center (866) 501-7271
CM says: Exotic itinerary, balcony cabins from $849, a great cruise bargain
hr blue bar
CruiseMates Allure Group Cruise!
Join CruiseMates on Allure of the Seas: October 2, 2011 From $779 per person.
•  Cruise Planners 1-800-561-0802
CM says: Our new Allure group cruise - lower prices!
hr blue bar
hr blue bar
hr blue bar
You can access all of these specials above - or go to CruiseMates' Cruise Bargains for even more!
hr blue bar
more about

CruiseMates, a popular online resource for unbiased and authoritative cruise information, features ship reviews and articles, cruise news, polls, message boards and more.

NEW YORK TIMES: "Many sites that offer reviews are selling cruises, which raises questions about impartiality. An exception is CruiseMates."

FORTUNE MAGAZINE: "The Web's best site for articles, advice, or chatting with Cruise People. Self-financed and run independently of the industry, so their opinions are impartial."


"CruiseMates Newsletter"

One of the best cruise travel newsletters anywhere! We feature cutting edge news stories you won't see anyplace else and commentary about a variety of cruise topics. Also get cruise bargain hunting tips, listings of actual cruise bargains, previews of our latest articles and news about our Cruisemates Group Cruises.


  hr blue bar  

We are an online, interactive CRUISE SHIP GUIDE with ship reviews, features articles, message boards and more. Recommended by: New York Times, Wall Street Journal, CNN Television, a Forbes Magazine "Best of the Web" site.

Prices listed are cruise only, per person, double occupancy and include port charges (also called non-commissionable cruise fare).

Fuel surcharges and government taxes & fees are additional unless otherwise noted. Prices are in US dollars, airfare is extra unless otherwise noted. Limited availability and restrictions may apply. Prices are subject to change without prior notice. Typographical errors may occur. Offers apply to new bookings only.

CruiseMates.com is an Internet Brands, Inc. website. Internet Brands is located at 909 North Sepulveda Blvd., 11th Floor, El Segundo, CA 90245 — This email was sent to %%#EMAIL%%. If you no longer wish to receive our emails please click here.

  © 2010 Internet Brands