cruisemates newsletter

cruise ship
Commentary by Editor Paul Motter

is crusing safe

We would like to put the sinking of the MV Sea Diamond into perspective. This Greek vessel was not held to the same safety standards as the cruise ships normally covered within the pages of CruiseMates.

The cruise lines readily available to the U.S. cruising public, including Carnival, Celebrity, Holland America, Norwegian Cruise Lines, Princess, Royal Caribbean and all the other names you are familiar with, are all members of the Cruise Line International Association and the International Council of Cruise Lines (recently merged).

These ships visit U.S. ports regularly, where they must pass strict scrutiny of their safety standards during frequent inspections by the U.S. Coast Guard. These inspections include everything safety related; smoke detectors, fire extinguishers, computer navigation systems and the rigging of life boats. Crews on these ships are given monthly safety drills which the Coast Guard will witness without notice, in addition to passenger drills on each cruise.

In truth, we had never heard of the MV Sea Diamond, but we found a vessel we would not recommend to our readers. Built in 1986, refurbished in 1999,and joining Louis Hellenic Cruises of Louis plc, listed on the Cyprus Stock Exchange in 2006, MV Sea Diamond was a mere 22,412 gross tons, yet it carried 1500 passengers in a mere 584 cabins serviced by only four elevators. CLIA- member cruise ships of this size rarely carry more than 300 passengers.

Therefore, we regret that this incident has been portrayed elsewhere as just another "cruise ship disaster" as if there is no distinction between this passenger conveyance vessel, which we would describe more accurately as a ferry, and the true cruise ships to which our pages are dedicated. A ship went down due to a captain's human error, an event of the utmost serious nature. But we can testify that we believe no captain we ever met would allow such a lapse in judgement.

For further discussion, please see our Cruise News and our Cruise News Message Boards.

gray hr
CruiseMates Cruise Bargains Virtual Shopping Mall
Where else can you go and see hundreds of cruise bargains from the web's top agencies all in one place? Bargains by cruising regions and classifed ads.
gray hr

new feature articles

gray hr
We Want YOUR Articles
CruiseMates wants articles by aspining travel writers. Maybe you met a staff member who was especially interesting, recently organized a family cruise, or learned something about cruising the world needs to know. Hopefully you have somethng to say to the world of cruise enthusiasts that will make their lives better, or at least brighten their day. more informatin.
gray hr

read about cruisemate

"Many sites that offer reviews are selling cruises, which raises questions about impartiality. An exceptions is CruiseMates."

"The Web's best site for articles, advice, or chatting with Cruise People. Self-financed and run independently of the industry, so their opinions are impartial"

blue arrows

Royal Caribbean
Freedom of the Seas

7 Night Western Caribbean from $699 pp!
Exclusive savings and FREE upgrades on select dates! Oceanview from $849.

new cruisemate's cruises

We have a NEW CruiseMates cruise that is a STEAL!

A 14-night transatlantic cruise, April 2008, from Florida to the Caribbean then to Europe including the Canary Islands, Spain, Florence Italy and ending in Rome - starting as low as $699 per person. This one is filling up fast!

7 nights in the Eastern Caribbean on Carnival Freedom, Thanksgiving, 2007.

where the bargains are

Norwegian Cruise Lines! The annual NCL Sale of all Sails is on right now!
Get up to $450 in onboard credit to spend as you please. Contact your travel agent. Other hot deals...
  • From $859 pp NCL Norwegian Pearl - 9 Night Southern Caribbean - Miami roundtrip
  • From $209 pp Carnival Paradise - 4 Night Mexico from L.A. to Catalina and Ensenada
  • From $949 pp 15-night Europe! NCL Norwegian Jewel trans-atlantic cruise

Save up to 75%
on Last-Minute Cruise!

Unsold cruise cabins are slashed in price within 90 days of departure. Check out a complete, up-todate listing of deeply discounted cruises from all the major cruise lines.

cruise news


Kiplinger's Magazine named CruiseMates to its
25 Best Value Travel Sites for 2006

Cruisemates is the most useful cruise-review site. We especially like its advice columns, which are written for people of different ages and interests.