Carnival Magic Reviews

Passengers: 4,631
Crew Members: 1369
Length: 1004 ft
Tonnage: 130,000

Go
  • Editor's Rating

    Very Good
    • Cuisine

      3.0
    • Service Level

      4.0
    • Value for Money

      4.0
    • Ship Décor

      3.0
    • Public Rooms

      3.0
    • Staterooms

      4.0
    • Kid's Programs

      5.0
    • Daytime Activities

      5.0
    • Nightlife

      5.0
    • Shore Tours

      3.0
    • Itinerary

      2.0
    • Alternative Dining

      3.0
  • Average User Ratings

    9 User Reviews

Carnival Magic Editor's Review

Overview

Dream-class; Outdoor SportsSquare, Cucina del Capitano, Cherry on Top, RedFrog Pub and RumRunners Tequila Bar

Best For People Who Want

Exciting and ritzy nightlife; numerous singles; alternative dining venues; the largest ship in the Carnival fleet; spacious cabins for three and four passengers; cabins with balconies; excellent fitness and spa facilities; high-energy atmosphere with varied daytime activities, including abundant children's programs.

Should Be Avoided By People Who Prefer

An elegant, quiet and relaxing cruise; private areas away from the public, especially children.

Onboard Experience

The 130,000-ton, 3,646-passenger Carnival Magic is the second edition of the largest Carnival cruise ship class to date, although it is still merely about 60% the size of the newest Royal Caribbean ships. Carnival has chosen not to go as large as some of it competitors. In fact, Magic is not a radically different Carnival ship even if it is the second ship from the first all new design Carnival has made in a decade. The biggest changes are a slightly subdued decor compared to previous Carnival ships, and a new entertainment venue called the "Ocean Bar" with outdoor seating on the promenade deck with cantilevered hot tubs close by.

There are certain aspects of Magic which it was the first to introduce to Carnival Cruise Lines: SportSquare, the fitness-and-fun area featuring the first ropes course at sea. Cucina del Capitano, Carnival's first-of-its-kind onboard Italian family-style dining experience. Cherry on Top, our sweet new candy-and-more store. RedFrog Pub, featuring Carnival's own ThirstyFrog Red — not to mention Caribbean-inspired appetizers, food and rum flights.

Another innovation on Carnival Magic is the "Fun Hub." These computer stations around the ship are not only internet connected but are also onboard networks for "social networking" with other cruisers. You can leave messages for people in your group or you can post messages for the whole ship to see. For example, if you brought your digeridoo and you want to have an Aussie jam session, you can suggest that all fellow aboriginals meet you on the pool deck at 2:00.

Not to poke fun, we actually think this is one of the better ideas any cruise ship has had for a long time. We at CruiseMates have always said that what ships need is better ways for like-minded individuals to meet on ships. You could have people from your high school just down the hall and not even realize it. It is a small world, and as far as we are concerned, Carnival is just helping to make it a friendlier place - not to mention the practical aspects of such a system.

Decor

One of the best aspects about Carnival Magic is less focus on the Farcusian decor (refering to Joe Farcus, the famous decorator of previous Carnival ships known for being outlandish. Compared to other Carnival ships, Magic is one of the least garish ships in the fleet. There isn't any neon (the days replaced by the more efficient LED) tubing along the railings. The look is glass with chrome railings and wood finishings. There are a lot of pinlights of different colors, but you won't be over-stimulated as you might be on other Carnival ships.

Public Rooms

Carnival Magic has a unique indoor/outdoor café and entertainment venue called Ocean Plaza in the mid-ships Promenade Deck. This is a first at sea, a public room with outdoor seating so close to the water line. Nearby the lanai seating are cantilevered hot tubs. The centerpiece of Ocean Plaza will be Plaza Café, a patisserie serving lattes, cappuccinos, espresso and other specialty coffees, along with sweets such as baked-on-board cakes, pies, cookies - even freshly made milkshakes. Full bar service, specializing in martinis, mojitos and other popular cocktails, will be offered, as well.

Magic's public rooms are breathtaking, with its imposing atrium covering ten decks and glass elevators to the Pool deck. The "Promenade" on Deck 5 includes benches along its boulevard for those wishing to rest between stops at the nearby wine bar, casino and the adult disco "Caliente Dance Club." The ship's nightclubs, primarily at the stern, include The Burgundy Lounge which becomes a comedy club four nights per week. The Song Jazz Lounge features one or two musicians playing classics of the 70's, 80's on the stage near its small dance floor. Sam's Piano Bar, a sing-along piano bar, is close to the Caliente Dance Club.

On the opposite end of Magic is the three-deck high Encore Main Lounge; aim for the lower balcony seats, a little off-center for the best view. Walking aft you next enter the Magic Atrium with the shopping area Fun Ships. The Jackpot Casino is the largest in the Carnival Fleet. Nearby the is the FunHub station just off the aforementioned Ocean Plaza. Hidden on Deck 4 (Atlantic Deck) are the extensive children's facilities including the Warehouse video-arcade and the two teen's discos, Circle C and Club 02. There are extensive conference facilities onboard on deck four.

Other diversions include a small library open for several hours each day and various boutiques selling a wide range of duty-free jewelry, perfume, and alcohol along with the usual cruise items.

Outside on the stern is a two-level Serenity adults-only retreat - the largest in the Carnival Fleet. The extensive water park along with a 23,750-square-foot health spa are both Carnival's largest to date.

Cuisine

Magic offers attractive breakfast and lunch buffets, including an excellent salad bar and made-to-order dishes. For those with a sophisticated palate, the new menus feature chateaubriand, rack of lamb, and lobster, along with chocolate desserts. Delightful specialties can be found on the second tier of the Cezanne Restaurant and include the Sur Mer seafood station and an Asian food station that regularly rotates its dishes. There's a complimentary sushi bar on the Promenade Deck in the evenings, and vegetarian and low-salt items on every menu and at all stations.

Restaurants

The two main dining rooms onboard are The Northern Lights Restaurant, midships, and the Southern Lights Restaurant in the stern. Both are two decks tall with their main entrances somewhat buried on deck three. Guests have their choice of six different appetizers and soups, two salads and six entrees each night. Also, Carnival Classics selections, including char-broiled steak made with the line's signature rub, grilled chicken and pasta dishes, along with a decadent dessert menu offering six different selections, including the cruise industry's most popular dessert - the Warm Chocolate Melting Cake - are offered nightly.

Carnival's Total Choice Dining provides for four seating times for a table in the Crimson Dining rooms at 5:45 or 6:15 p.m. and 8 or 8:30 p.m.. For those who prefer to dine when the mood strikes them can eat in the Scarlet Restaurant or at the poolside Lido restaurant which is offers buffet dinners between 6:00 and 9:00 p.m., no reservations required.

For those seeking more health-conscious cuisine, dining room menus feature Spa Carnival Fare selections, delicious, guilt-free items that are lower in calories, cholesterol, sodium and fat content. Vegetarian choices and children's menus are available, as well.

There is a two-level casual eatery called The LIdo Marketplace, offering breakfast, lunch and dinner. Culinary choices include Italian and Tex-Mex to tandoori and Asian specialties. A pasta bar will offer guests their choice of pasta, sauce and ingredients to create a custom-made dish of traditional Italian favorites such as Portobello ravioli or pasta carbonara. The Gathering will also house Carnival's popular 24-hour pizzeria with seven kinds of pies and calzone, Caesar salad and garlic bread.

Carnival Magic's burrito bar is also sure to be a popular spot where guests can create an overstuffed wrap featuring their choice of chicken, beef, shrimp, salsa and other accompaniments.

Also available within The Gathering will be a Mongolian wok offering custom-made stir-fries with guests' choice of meat and vegetables and finished with one of Carnival's signature sauces; Taste of the Nations, featuring a different international cuisine each day; a New York-style deli; a tandoori oven offering Indian-style chicken, fish and meatballs, along with traditional bread, chutneys and relishes; and a grille serving hot dogs, hamburgers and grilled chicken sandwiches.

The Gathering will also offer an extensive 35-item salad bar, 24-hour frozen yogurt, low-calorie dressings and sugar-free desserts for guests seeking healthier alternatives.

An expanded 24-hour room service menu will include new choices such as Medium Rare Roast Beef and Brie on French Baguette and Grilled Fresh Mozzarella and Portobello Mushroom on Focaccia. Room service orders are delivered to guests' staterooms any time of the day or night at no charge.

Located along Promenade Deck will be Wasabi, a sushi bar serving complimentary sushi, as well as sake.

For those seeking a more intimate dining experience, The Chef's Art, Carnival Magic's steakhouse-style restaurant, will offer delectable cuisine in memorable surroundings. Located on Spa Deck 12, this 139-seat venue offers a sumptuous menu of prime dry-aged U.S.D.A. beef - selections include a nine-ounce filet, 14-ounce strip loin, 18-ounce grilled prime rib chop and 24-ounce porterhouse - along with lobster tail, lamb chops, Chilean sea bass, Maine Lobster ravioli and more. Creamed spinach, Wasabi mashed potatoes, sautéed mushrooms and traditional sauces complete the steakhouse experience.

The delicious choices, combined with attentive service and an extensive wine list, make a meal at The Chef's Art truly unforgettable. Reservations are recommended and there is a charge of $30 per person.

Previously exclusive to Carnival Magic but now added to Dream and also to be included on Carnival Breeze is the new Ocean Plaza, a spectacular indoor/outdoor café and entertainment venue designed for guests to relax and people watch. In addition to a dance floor and a stage featuring live entertainment, Ocean Plaza will offer full Wi-Fi access, along with 12 stand-alone kiosks where guests can access the FunHub, Carnival Magic's comprehensive portal and exclusive on-board social network.

Service

The staff on the Magic is prompt, well-organized, and prone to showing off, as when balancing trays on their heads while serving dessert. The maitre'd makes a point of learning the names of all couples celebrating an anniversary.

Tipping

All Carnival cruises have a $10.00 per person per day (excluding children under two years of age) gratuity comprising $5.50 for the Dining Room service, $3.60 for the stateroom steward, and $.90 for the alternative dining rooms. This charge can be either automatically added to the Sail & Sign card or it can be prepaid (prepayment is mandatory on the Cruises-to-Nowhere). The purser's desk can decrease or increase this amount throughout the cruise. Tip room service, the maitre d', casino, spa, or other staff as you deem fit. The bar and beverage tabs all include a 15 percent gratuity to the bill.

Entertainment

One of the new entertainment attractions on Magic include a new comedy club, to be held in the 425-seat Burgundy Lounge. It offers six shows per night, alternating between two commedians. The last two shows of the evening will be the adults only shows, one offered by each commedian. Making it even better, half-way through the cruise Carnival will bring in two different comedians for two fresh shows. This means that all together there will be eight different comedy shows for each passenger to see, a "family" and an "R-rated" show from each of four different comedians.

Carnival has a laser light show that goes off every night with a different theme. The laser-works are choreographed to songs by different well-known rock bands like Styx and Van Halen, Rush and Pink Floyd. Smoke machines enhance the laser effects.

The ship has three different major production shows in the main theater, "Encore," each week-long cruise. Sam's is a sing-a-long piano bar. Caliente is the disco dance club with a high-tech sound and lighting system. Ocean Plaza is the new indoor/outdoor cafe/entertainment venue on the Promenade deck that will showcase various styles of music as well as art, photo and spa seminars, scrapbooking classes, magicians, jugglers, trivia contests and more. An acrobatic troupe called Fun Force will entertain guests in Ocean Plaza and at various venues around the ship.

The main Showtime Theater presents outstanding production shows featuring beautiful costumes and Vegas-quality light shows, but even the smaller venues have great acts and music, particularly the sing-along piano bar. There is a Caribbean band on the pool deck. More interactive activities include numerous bingo games, art auctions, ballroom dancing, karaoke, and "game show mania".

Cabins

Several new accommodation categories, including five-berth, two-bathroom staterooms especially for families, will be offered. There is also a new style of balcony cabin called the Cove Balcony located on surprisingly lower decks, below the promenade decks. These balconies are shadier than the higher ones as they are built into the hull of the ship.

The suites and ocean view staterooms come with complimentary bathrobes and a mini bar. The cabins located on the outside are 220 sq. feet and include a coffee table and plush leather sofa. The inside cabins are 195 sq. feet in area and are great for families or large groups of singles due to their pull-down berths that provide extra sleeping space. Families might prefer the 230 sq. feet cabins located next to the children's center. All the large bathrooms include a shower (the suites are the only cabins with tubs), basket of toiletries, and hair dryer. The cabins come standard with a color TV that includes ESPN, CNN, and movies. There is plentiful storage space, with three closets and a several drawers. for those of special needs are available.

Fitness/Spa

The gym's 15,000 sq.. feet is full of treadmills, stationary bikes, stairmasters, rowing and hydraulic weight machines, and of course free weights. The strategically placed equipment allows you to enjoy the lovely panoramic views offered by the floor-to-ceiling windows. For runners, a lap on the jogging deck, which surrounds the smokestack, is equivalent to 1/11 of a mile.

Attire

The attire on cruises became decidedly less formal at the end of the 2000's, and now even formal nights are merely suggestions. Most men wear dark jackets and ties are optional. While jeans aren't technically allowed in the dining room no one is going to stop you from entering. Daytime wear is strictly casual.

Carnival Magic Ratings

  • EDITORS
  • 3.0
  • USERS
  • 3.3
from 9 reviews
DETAILED RATINGS
  •  
    EDITORS
    USERS
  • Cuisine
    3.0
    2.0
  • Service Level
    4.0
    3.5
  • Value for Money
    4.0
    2.8
  • Ship Décor
    3.0
    3.5
  • Public Rooms
    3.0
    0.0
  • Staterooms
    4.0
    4.3
  • Kid's Programs
    5.0
    2.3
  • Daytime Activities
    5.0
    2.5
  • Nightlife
    5.0
    3.0
  • Shore Tours
    3.0
    3.8
  • Itinerary
    2.0
    3.5
  • Alternative Dining
    3.0
    3.3

Similar Cruise Ships

Carnival Breeze
Carnival Breeze
From 3 Reviews
Carnival Dream
Carnival Dream
From 22 Reviews