I liked the personal tipping prior to auto tipping so still add (in cash) to our servers and room stewards. I always wondered though if the people that skipped dinner on the last night didn't sleep in their cabin that night either. You knew they wouldn't show up for dinner because they wouldn't be tipping. Generally they were the ones that demanded service and were rude to the help. We have seen so many of them through the years. Shame, shame on them.